2941
Mach4 General Discussion / Re: CNC drive AXBB-E
« on: March 09, 2019, 03:47:02 PM »
Hi Russ,
PMDX has a great reputation and a loyal following.
Steve has stated in other threads that the PMDX Mach4 lathe threading feature is mature. Further I understand that
it will accommodate either spindle index signals OR spindle encoder signals. What is not clear, at least to me, is
whether PMDX supports PID, however the tone of Steve's replies suggests not.
As you are no doubt aware Mach3 assumed a near constant spindle speed during threading operations to ensure accurate
threading and reliable thread synchronization. Mach4 is very similar.
This has traditionally has meant that the spindle motor requires much greater torque than that required by the cutting action
on the workpiece, usually with significant rotational momentum. If your spindle is not sufficiently powerful or you are taking
deep and aggressive threading passes the quality of the thread degrades.
Warp9 TD elected to pair their lathe threading feature with spindle PID. This means that with suitable feedback, either
index or encoder, the spindle control analogue output will vary in a manner to restore the spindle speed. Potentially
allowing the use of a smaller less capable spindle than had hitherto been required. I have attached a screen shot of the
ESS plugin Spindle page to give you a sense of how Warp9 have done it.
Craig
PMDX has a great reputation and a loyal following.
Steve has stated in other threads that the PMDX Mach4 lathe threading feature is mature. Further I understand that
it will accommodate either spindle index signals OR spindle encoder signals. What is not clear, at least to me, is
whether PMDX supports PID, however the tone of Steve's replies suggests not.
As you are no doubt aware Mach3 assumed a near constant spindle speed during threading operations to ensure accurate
threading and reliable thread synchronization. Mach4 is very similar.
This has traditionally has meant that the spindle motor requires much greater torque than that required by the cutting action
on the workpiece, usually with significant rotational momentum. If your spindle is not sufficiently powerful or you are taking
deep and aggressive threading passes the quality of the thread degrades.
Warp9 TD elected to pair their lathe threading feature with spindle PID. This means that with suitable feedback, either
index or encoder, the spindle control analogue output will vary in a manner to restore the spindle speed. Potentially
allowing the use of a smaller less capable spindle than had hitherto been required. I have attached a screen shot of the
ESS plugin Spindle page to give you a sense of how Warp9 have done it.
Craig