40
« on: November 28, 2015, 11:07:18 AM »
I am having an issue quantifying just what is responsible for smooth and fast motion on a PP based PC.
I have always used computers that met the minimum requirements of Mach 3. Some PC's propel my machines to seemingly unuseable speeds and others stall, same controllers, same settings in Mach. Just different PC's.
I have used the optimization steps in Mach and checked and or changed my port status etc.
Many times during the pursuit of speeds attained prior I would hear a clicking coming from the steppers.
I have only read a few other threads that mention this. In my case it always sounded mechanical and had me adjusting gibs and bearings, lubricating, cleaning etc. Never to improve.
Just lately I was finally smart enough the remove the steppers from my lathe only to find the sound was still there. I drove the axis by hand and was amazed at the smoothness and lack of effort required to move any of the axis'.
Friction is not causing my stalling issues. Nor are the speeds I am asking of the steppers.
Changing the acceleration has no effect nor turning the toolpath on or off.
Searching the forums for a specific mobo, RAM, graphics card with guaranteed success almost impossible. Is it the software? The parallel port itself? A graphics card? I cant imagine it is luck of the draw.
I realize that I could use a motion controller of some flavor. I have a few. However my stubbornness makes me pursue WHY? As mentioned above I have had great success with the PP. No need to change if I can find out why.
Here are 2 different screenshots of the DriverTest results, not mine just pics from the net. Looking at the results of the tests and the signals. Which would be the better computer to use and why?
Both are testing at the same speed.
Both claim system excellent.