why wouldn't that work reliably Ray? The signal (from a C23 board) is split and both motor drivers (gecko 203v's) receive that signal. Or were you thinking I was using one motor driver for two motors?
"The controller is the same for both X axis stepper motors, so if it works on one, it should work on both." - So now you're saying it's NOT the same controller for both. Each motor has it's own G203V, right? So swap the motor wires between the two G203Vs. If the problem moves to the other motor, then you have a G203V that is either hosed, or improperly setup. If not, then swap the motors themselves. If the problem follows the motor, then you have your answer. If not, then the problem is mechanical. Steppers will almost always either work correctly, or not at all.
My money would be on a mechanical problem....
Regards,
Ray L.