1334
« on: February 18, 2009, 01:02:43 PM »
You need to figure out exactly what functionality you need, before you can choose a BOB, or rule out the SmoothStepper. What step rates do you need to achieve to get your target rapid rates? Since you're apparently using servos, your step rates may be quite high - beyond what a parallel port can support. Mine run 20K and 96K steps/inch, so getting reasonable rapid rates means running beyond what a PP can support (the PP usually tops out at 45kHz). You may also get smoother, more reliable operation with the SS - I sure did. If you do use the SS, not all BOBs will work well with it. I know the CNC4PC C11 will not - I had to modify mine to make it work abouve 40kHz step rate (and the spindle speed control is very unreliable....) Not sure about the C11T, but I suspect it uses very similar circuitry. For the BOB, do you need spindle speed control? If so, what kind - Step/Dir or PWM? What voltage range? Not all the BOBs you list support spindle speed control, so you'd have to buy an additional spindle control board, in addition to the BOB. How many relays do you need? Many systems will require at least 3: Spindle CW, Spindle CCW, and Coolant. Some need even more. Do you want/need opto-islolation? If you're using Geckos, you don't need this on the Step/Dir signals, but may still want it on the other signals, to help with noise immunity on limit/home switches, etc.
Regards,
Ray L.