6956
« on: October 30, 2008, 07:47:45 PM »
simpson36,
I would quess that the rack and pinion on your mill is not adjustable such that you can adjust the mesh of the gear to
the rack. And if you could and did you would probably end up with a tight spot because the rack and pinion is not precision. You have the equivilent of screw backlash in the rack and pinion. You can take out some of it when change in direction occurs using backlash compensation, it will help minimiize it, but not eliminate it. I have the same problem with my quilled mill directly driven via the fine movement gearing. I jog it down to take the play out, but on retract, even with backlash compensation, the Z accuracy is not repeatable.
Yes, a few sweet spots, but in general not in the one to 3 thou range. So for general milliing I can work around it,but,
for engraving requiring very precise movement, forget it.
Positioning the head via ball screw should eliminate your problem. Make sure that part of the system has adequate torque
to hold position and microstep.
Now just as an option to consider and if you can live with the tolerance of the belt driven rack......you can add another
removable compact / short ball screw movement driven spindle for fine work. Just a thought.
RICH