6
« on: January 31, 2016, 10:52:08 AM »
Don
I'll share what I have encountered with my retrofit. My servo are rated at 150vdc 50amps. I started with the Gecko G320X drives. They work good are very smooth and quiet. Tuning is tricky but once you get the feel you can set them to a nice smooth run. The G320X is rated for a max of 80vdc at 20 amps which so far has ran the X and Y with no problems and plenty of power. I have been running this machine for 3 years in a fab shop so it see's a lot of work. The Z axis burns out the G320 after about 6 months. My mill is a bed mill with a large head and just needs more power than the Gecko can deliver. After losing a couple of the Geco's to this I stepped up to a Dugong 160 35 drive. As you can guess it is rated at 160vdc and 35 amps. This drive throws the Z axis around with no problems and can run much faster than I care to move that much weight. Now the draw back of this drive is that its noisy compared to the Gecko and the tuning is done through software. There is a scope in the software for pid tuning to see the effects of dampening which is very helpful in getting it right.
The specs of your motors are well within the specs of the Gecko and they would probably work good for you retrofit. If you use the Gecko drive be sure to put them on a good heat sink, they are very small and won't cool very good on their own. Something they don't mention in the paperwork provided with the drives.
Good luck hope this helps.
Steve