1
Mach4 General Discussion / Re: mc.mcToolGetSelected(inst) issue In lathe mode
« on: April 20, 2020, 12:33:13 PM »
Please find below our conversation of one year ago (I stop the retrofit for a long time, I was too busy).
I think we misunderstand between lathe threading and tapping with a milling machine, I'm not sure.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
>>> Can you confirm me rigid tapping is supported ?
It's a bit complicated, but I'll try to explain it to you.
Some time ago I tested Mach4, and it showed up that it has the threading function with a screw tap, but the function doesn't include spindle rotary speed synchronization with Z-axis feed rate. This threading requires compensation holder, so rigid tapping is not possible.
I talked to our software developers and asked them if they add the rigid tapping function (M84) just like in Mach3.
I got the information that they won't as this will cause many issues.
Mach4 is constructed this way so it controls everything and implementing the autonomous rigid tapping function may cause some conflicts.
---------------------------------
I hope this help you ...
From my side, I really wonder if I'll go on with mach3, mach4 or another electronic good quality this time (if you know one good...). I can't imagine having no possibility to make threading with a CNC lathe !!!
The NUM760 I remove frome my lathe, from 1990 (30 years ago !!) use to do it ...
For me it does not appear to be so complicated.
I think we misunderstand between lathe threading and tapping with a milling machine, I'm not sure.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
>>> Can you confirm me rigid tapping is supported ?
It's a bit complicated, but I'll try to explain it to you.
Some time ago I tested Mach4, and it showed up that it has the threading function with a screw tap, but the function doesn't include spindle rotary speed synchronization with Z-axis feed rate. This threading requires compensation holder, so rigid tapping is not possible.
I talked to our software developers and asked them if they add the rigid tapping function (M84) just like in Mach3.
I got the information that they won't as this will cause many issues.
Mach4 is constructed this way so it controls everything and implementing the autonomous rigid tapping function may cause some conflicts.
---------------------------------
I hope this help you ...
From my side, I really wonder if I'll go on with mach3, mach4 or another electronic good quality this time (if you know one good...). I can't imagine having no possibility to make threading with a CNC lathe !!!
The NUM760 I remove frome my lathe, from 1990 (30 years ago !!) use to do it ...
For me it does not appear to be so complicated.